• Home
  • Line#
  • Scopes#
  • Navigate#
  • Raw
  • Download
1 /*
2  *
3  * Copyright 2015 gRPC authors.
4  *
5  * Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
6  * you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
7  * You may obtain a copy of the License at
8  *
9  *     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
10  *
11  * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
12  * distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
13  * WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
14  * See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
15  * limitations under the License.
16  *
17  */
18 
19 #include <grpc/support/port_platform.h>
20 
21 #include "src/core/lib/transport/metadata.h"
22 
23 #include <assert.h>
24 #include <inttypes.h>
25 #include <stddef.h>
26 #include <string.h>
27 
28 #include <grpc/compression.h>
29 #include <grpc/grpc.h>
30 #include <grpc/support/alloc.h>
31 #include <grpc/support/atm.h>
32 #include <grpc/support/log.h>
33 #include <grpc/support/string_util.h>
34 #include <grpc/support/time.h>
35 
36 #include "src/core/lib/gpr/murmur_hash.h"
37 #include "src/core/lib/gpr/string.h"
38 #include "src/core/lib/iomgr/iomgr_internal.h"
39 #include "src/core/lib/profiling/timers.h"
40 #include "src/core/lib/slice/slice_internal.h"
41 #include "src/core/lib/slice/slice_string_helpers.h"
42 #include "src/core/lib/transport/static_metadata.h"
43 
44 /* There are two kinds of mdelem and mdstr instances.
45  * Static instances are declared in static_metadata.{h,c} and
46  * are initialized by grpc_mdctx_global_init().
47  * Dynamic instances are stored in hash tables on grpc_mdctx, and are backed
48  * by internal_string and internal_element structures.
49  * Internal helper functions here-in (is_mdstr_static, is_mdelem_static) are
50  * used to determine which kind of element a pointer refers to.
51  */
52 
53 grpc_core::DebugOnlyTraceFlag grpc_trace_metadata(false, "metadata");
54 
55 #ifndef NDEBUG
56 #define DEBUG_ARGS , const char *file, int line
57 #define FWD_DEBUG_ARGS , file, line
58 #define REF_MD_LOCKED(shard, s) ref_md_locked((shard), (s), __FILE__, __LINE__)
59 #else
60 #define DEBUG_ARGS
61 #define FWD_DEBUG_ARGS
62 #define REF_MD_LOCKED(shard, s) ref_md_locked((shard), (s))
63 #endif
64 
65 #define INITIAL_SHARD_CAPACITY 8
66 #define LOG2_SHARD_COUNT 4
67 #define SHARD_COUNT ((size_t)(1 << LOG2_SHARD_COUNT))
68 
69 #define TABLE_IDX(hash, capacity) (((hash) >> (LOG2_SHARD_COUNT)) % (capacity))
70 #define SHARD_IDX(hash) ((hash) & ((1 << (LOG2_SHARD_COUNT)) - 1))
71 
72 typedef void (*destroy_user_data_func)(void* user_data);
73 
74 /* Shadow structure for grpc_mdelem_data for interned elements */
75 typedef struct interned_metadata {
76   /* must be byte compatible with grpc_mdelem_data */
77   grpc_slice key;
78   grpc_slice value;
79 
80   /* private only data */
81   gpr_atm refcnt;
82 
83   gpr_mu mu_user_data;
84   gpr_atm destroy_user_data;
85   gpr_atm user_data;
86 
87   struct interned_metadata* bucket_next;
88 } interned_metadata;
89 
90 /* Shadow structure for grpc_mdelem_data for allocated elements */
91 typedef struct allocated_metadata {
92   /* must be byte compatible with grpc_mdelem_data */
93   grpc_slice key;
94   grpc_slice value;
95 
96   /* private only data */
97   gpr_atm refcnt;
98 } allocated_metadata;
99 
100 typedef struct mdtab_shard {
101   gpr_mu mu;
102   interned_metadata** elems;
103   size_t count;
104   size_t capacity;
105   /** Estimate of the number of unreferenced mdelems in the hash table.
106       This will eventually converge to the exact number, but it's instantaneous
107       accuracy is not guaranteed */
108   gpr_atm free_estimate;
109 } mdtab_shard;
110 
111 static mdtab_shard g_shards[SHARD_COUNT];
112 
113 static void gc_mdtab(mdtab_shard* shard);
114 
grpc_mdctx_global_init(void)115 void grpc_mdctx_global_init(void) {
116   /* initialize shards */
117   for (size_t i = 0; i < SHARD_COUNT; i++) {
118     mdtab_shard* shard = &g_shards[i];
119     gpr_mu_init(&shard->mu);
120     shard->count = 0;
121     gpr_atm_no_barrier_store(&shard->free_estimate, 0);
122     shard->capacity = INITIAL_SHARD_CAPACITY;
123     shard->elems = static_cast<interned_metadata**>(
124         gpr_zalloc(sizeof(*shard->elems) * shard->capacity));
125   }
126 }
127 
grpc_mdctx_global_shutdown()128 void grpc_mdctx_global_shutdown() {
129   for (size_t i = 0; i < SHARD_COUNT; i++) {
130     mdtab_shard* shard = &g_shards[i];
131     gpr_mu_destroy(&shard->mu);
132     gc_mdtab(shard);
133     /* TODO(ctiller): GPR_ASSERT(shard->count == 0); */
134     if (shard->count != 0) {
135       gpr_log(GPR_DEBUG, "WARNING: %" PRIuPTR " metadata elements were leaked",
136               shard->count);
137       if (grpc_iomgr_abort_on_leaks()) {
138         abort();
139       }
140     }
141     gpr_free(shard->elems);
142   }
143 }
144 
is_mdelem_static(grpc_mdelem e)145 static int is_mdelem_static(grpc_mdelem e) {
146   return GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(e) >= &grpc_static_mdelem_table[0] &&
147          GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(e) <
148              &grpc_static_mdelem_table[GRPC_STATIC_MDELEM_COUNT];
149 }
150 
ref_md_locked(mdtab_shard * shard,interned_metadata * md DEBUG_ARGS)151 static void ref_md_locked(mdtab_shard* shard,
152                           interned_metadata* md DEBUG_ARGS) {
153 #ifndef NDEBUG
154   if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
155     char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->key);
156     char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->value);
157     gpr_log(file, line, GPR_LOG_SEVERITY_DEBUG,
158             "ELM   REF:%p:%" PRIdPTR "->%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'", (void*)md,
159             gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt),
160             gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt) + 1, key_str, value_str);
161     gpr_free(key_str);
162     gpr_free(value_str);
163   }
164 #endif
165   if (0 == gpr_atm_no_barrier_fetch_add(&md->refcnt, 1)) {
166     gpr_atm_no_barrier_fetch_add(&shard->free_estimate, -1);
167   }
168 }
169 
gc_mdtab(mdtab_shard * shard)170 static void gc_mdtab(mdtab_shard* shard) {
171   GPR_TIMER_SCOPE("gc_mdtab", 0);
172 
173   size_t i;
174   interned_metadata** prev_next;
175   interned_metadata *md, *next;
176   gpr_atm num_freed = 0;
177 
178   for (i = 0; i < shard->capacity; i++) {
179     prev_next = &shard->elems[i];
180     for (md = shard->elems[i]; md; md = next) {
181       void* user_data = (void*)gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->user_data);
182       next = md->bucket_next;
183       if (gpr_atm_acq_load(&md->refcnt) == 0) {
184         grpc_slice_unref_internal(md->key);
185         grpc_slice_unref_internal(md->value);
186         if (md->user_data) {
187           ((destroy_user_data_func)gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(
188               &md->destroy_user_data))(user_data);
189         }
190         gpr_free(md);
191         *prev_next = next;
192         num_freed++;
193         shard->count--;
194       } else {
195         prev_next = &md->bucket_next;
196       }
197     }
198   }
199   gpr_atm_no_barrier_fetch_add(&shard->free_estimate, -num_freed);
200 }
201 
grow_mdtab(mdtab_shard * shard)202 static void grow_mdtab(mdtab_shard* shard) {
203   GPR_TIMER_SCOPE("grow_mdtab", 0);
204 
205   size_t capacity = shard->capacity * 2;
206   size_t i;
207   interned_metadata** mdtab;
208   interned_metadata *md, *next;
209   uint32_t hash;
210 
211   mdtab = static_cast<interned_metadata**>(
212       gpr_zalloc(sizeof(interned_metadata*) * capacity));
213 
214   for (i = 0; i < shard->capacity; i++) {
215     for (md = shard->elems[i]; md; md = next) {
216       size_t idx;
217       hash = GRPC_MDSTR_KV_HASH(grpc_slice_hash(md->key),
218                                 grpc_slice_hash(md->value));
219       next = md->bucket_next;
220       idx = TABLE_IDX(hash, capacity);
221       md->bucket_next = mdtab[idx];
222       mdtab[idx] = md;
223     }
224   }
225   gpr_free(shard->elems);
226   shard->elems = mdtab;
227   shard->capacity = capacity;
228 }
229 
rehash_mdtab(mdtab_shard * shard)230 static void rehash_mdtab(mdtab_shard* shard) {
231   if (gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&shard->free_estimate) >
232       static_cast<gpr_atm>(shard->capacity / 4)) {
233     gc_mdtab(shard);
234   } else {
235     grow_mdtab(shard);
236   }
237 }
238 
grpc_mdelem_create(grpc_slice key,grpc_slice value,grpc_mdelem_data * compatible_external_backing_store)239 grpc_mdelem grpc_mdelem_create(
240     grpc_slice key, grpc_slice value,
241     grpc_mdelem_data* compatible_external_backing_store) {
242   if (!grpc_slice_is_interned(key) || !grpc_slice_is_interned(value)) {
243     if (compatible_external_backing_store != nullptr) {
244       return GRPC_MAKE_MDELEM(compatible_external_backing_store,
245                               GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_EXTERNAL);
246     }
247 
248     allocated_metadata* allocated =
249         static_cast<allocated_metadata*>(gpr_malloc(sizeof(*allocated)));
250     allocated->key = grpc_slice_ref_internal(key);
251     allocated->value = grpc_slice_ref_internal(value);
252     gpr_atm_rel_store(&allocated->refcnt, 1);
253 #ifndef NDEBUG
254     if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
255       char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(allocated->key);
256       char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(allocated->value);
257       gpr_log(GPR_DEBUG, "ELM ALLOC:%p:%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'",
258               (void*)allocated, gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&allocated->refcnt),
259               key_str, value_str);
260       gpr_free(key_str);
261       gpr_free(value_str);
262     }
263 #endif
264     return GRPC_MAKE_MDELEM(allocated, GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_ALLOCATED);
265   }
266 
267   if (GRPC_IS_STATIC_METADATA_STRING(key) &&
268       GRPC_IS_STATIC_METADATA_STRING(value)) {
269     grpc_mdelem static_elem = grpc_static_mdelem_for_static_strings(
270         GRPC_STATIC_METADATA_INDEX(key), GRPC_STATIC_METADATA_INDEX(value));
271     if (!GRPC_MDISNULL(static_elem)) {
272       return static_elem;
273     }
274   }
275 
276   uint32_t hash =
277       GRPC_MDSTR_KV_HASH(grpc_slice_hash(key), grpc_slice_hash(value));
278   interned_metadata* md;
279   mdtab_shard* shard = &g_shards[SHARD_IDX(hash)];
280   size_t idx;
281 
282   GPR_TIMER_SCOPE("grpc_mdelem_from_metadata_strings", 0);
283 
284   gpr_mu_lock(&shard->mu);
285 
286   idx = TABLE_IDX(hash, shard->capacity);
287   /* search for an existing pair */
288   for (md = shard->elems[idx]; md; md = md->bucket_next) {
289     if (grpc_slice_eq(key, md->key) && grpc_slice_eq(value, md->value)) {
290       REF_MD_LOCKED(shard, md);
291       gpr_mu_unlock(&shard->mu);
292       return GRPC_MAKE_MDELEM(md, GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_INTERNED);
293     }
294   }
295 
296   /* not found: create a new pair */
297   md = static_cast<interned_metadata*>(gpr_malloc(sizeof(interned_metadata)));
298   gpr_atm_rel_store(&md->refcnt, 1);
299   md->key = grpc_slice_ref_internal(key);
300   md->value = grpc_slice_ref_internal(value);
301   md->user_data = 0;
302   md->destroy_user_data = 0;
303   md->bucket_next = shard->elems[idx];
304   shard->elems[idx] = md;
305   gpr_mu_init(&md->mu_user_data);
306 #ifndef NDEBUG
307   if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
308     char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->key);
309     char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->value);
310     gpr_log(GPR_DEBUG, "ELM   NEW:%p:%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'", (void*)md,
311             gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt), key_str, value_str);
312     gpr_free(key_str);
313     gpr_free(value_str);
314   }
315 #endif
316   shard->count++;
317 
318   if (shard->count > shard->capacity * 2) {
319     rehash_mdtab(shard);
320   }
321 
322   gpr_mu_unlock(&shard->mu);
323 
324   return GRPC_MAKE_MDELEM(md, GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_INTERNED);
325 }
326 
grpc_mdelem_from_slices(grpc_slice key,grpc_slice value)327 grpc_mdelem grpc_mdelem_from_slices(grpc_slice key, grpc_slice value) {
328   grpc_mdelem out = grpc_mdelem_create(key, value, nullptr);
329   grpc_slice_unref_internal(key);
330   grpc_slice_unref_internal(value);
331   return out;
332 }
333 
grpc_mdelem_from_grpc_metadata(grpc_metadata * metadata)334 grpc_mdelem grpc_mdelem_from_grpc_metadata(grpc_metadata* metadata) {
335   bool changed = false;
336   grpc_slice key_slice =
337       grpc_slice_maybe_static_intern(metadata->key, &changed);
338   grpc_slice value_slice =
339       grpc_slice_maybe_static_intern(metadata->value, &changed);
340   return grpc_mdelem_create(
341       key_slice, value_slice,
342       changed ? nullptr : reinterpret_cast<grpc_mdelem_data*>(metadata));
343 }
344 
grpc_mdelem_ref(grpc_mdelem gmd DEBUG_ARGS)345 grpc_mdelem grpc_mdelem_ref(grpc_mdelem gmd DEBUG_ARGS) {
346   switch (GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE(gmd)) {
347     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_EXTERNAL:
348     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_STATIC:
349       break;
350     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_INTERNED: {
351       interned_metadata* md =
352           reinterpret_cast<interned_metadata*> GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(gmd);
353 #ifndef NDEBUG
354       if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
355         char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->key);
356         char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->value);
357         gpr_log(file, line, GPR_LOG_SEVERITY_DEBUG,
358                 "ELM   REF:%p:%" PRIdPTR "->%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'",
359                 (void*)md, gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt),
360                 gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt) + 1, key_str, value_str);
361         gpr_free(key_str);
362         gpr_free(value_str);
363       }
364 #endif
365       /* we can assume the ref count is >= 1 as the application is calling
366          this function - meaning that no adjustment to mdtab_free is necessary,
367          simplifying the logic here to be just an atomic increment */
368       /* use C assert to have this removed in opt builds */
369       GPR_ASSERT(gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt) >= 1);
370       gpr_atm_no_barrier_fetch_add(&md->refcnt, 1);
371       break;
372     }
373     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_ALLOCATED: {
374       allocated_metadata* md =
375           reinterpret_cast<allocated_metadata*> GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(gmd);
376 #ifndef NDEBUG
377       if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
378         char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->key);
379         char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->value);
380         gpr_log(file, line, GPR_LOG_SEVERITY_DEBUG,
381                 "ELM   REF:%p:%" PRIdPTR "->%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'",
382                 (void*)md, gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt),
383                 gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt) + 1, key_str, value_str);
384         gpr_free(key_str);
385         gpr_free(value_str);
386       }
387 #endif
388       /* we can assume the ref count is >= 1 as the application is calling
389          this function - meaning that no adjustment to mdtab_free is necessary,
390          simplifying the logic here to be just an atomic increment */
391       /* use C assert to have this removed in opt builds */
392       gpr_atm_no_barrier_fetch_add(&md->refcnt, 1);
393       break;
394     }
395   }
396   return gmd;
397 }
398 
grpc_mdelem_unref(grpc_mdelem gmd DEBUG_ARGS)399 void grpc_mdelem_unref(grpc_mdelem gmd DEBUG_ARGS) {
400   switch (GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE(gmd)) {
401     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_EXTERNAL:
402     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_STATIC:
403       break;
404     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_INTERNED: {
405       interned_metadata* md =
406           reinterpret_cast<interned_metadata*> GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(gmd);
407 #ifndef NDEBUG
408       if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
409         char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->key);
410         char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->value);
411         gpr_log(file, line, GPR_LOG_SEVERITY_DEBUG,
412                 "ELM UNREF:%p:%" PRIdPTR "->%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'",
413                 (void*)md, gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt),
414                 gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt) - 1, key_str, value_str);
415         gpr_free(key_str);
416         gpr_free(value_str);
417       }
418 #endif
419       uint32_t hash = GRPC_MDSTR_KV_HASH(grpc_slice_hash(md->key),
420                                          grpc_slice_hash(md->value));
421       const gpr_atm prev_refcount = gpr_atm_full_fetch_add(&md->refcnt, -1);
422       GPR_ASSERT(prev_refcount >= 1);
423       if (1 == prev_refcount) {
424         /* once the refcount hits zero, some other thread can come along and
425            free md at any time: it's unsafe from this point on to access it */
426         mdtab_shard* shard = &g_shards[SHARD_IDX(hash)];
427         gpr_atm_no_barrier_fetch_add(&shard->free_estimate, 1);
428       }
429       break;
430     }
431     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_ALLOCATED: {
432       allocated_metadata* md =
433           reinterpret_cast<allocated_metadata*> GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(gmd);
434 #ifndef NDEBUG
435       if (grpc_trace_metadata.enabled()) {
436         char* key_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->key);
437         char* value_str = grpc_slice_to_c_string(md->value);
438         gpr_log(file, line, GPR_LOG_SEVERITY_DEBUG,
439                 "ELM UNREF:%p:%" PRIdPTR "->%" PRIdPTR ": '%s' = '%s'",
440                 (void*)md, gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt),
441                 gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&md->refcnt) - 1, key_str, value_str);
442         gpr_free(key_str);
443         gpr_free(value_str);
444       }
445 #endif
446       const gpr_atm prev_refcount = gpr_atm_full_fetch_add(&md->refcnt, -1);
447       GPR_ASSERT(prev_refcount >= 1);
448       if (1 == prev_refcount) {
449         grpc_slice_unref_internal(md->key);
450         grpc_slice_unref_internal(md->value);
451         gpr_free(md);
452       }
453       break;
454     }
455   }
456 }
457 
grpc_mdelem_get_user_data(grpc_mdelem md,void (* destroy_func)(void *))458 void* grpc_mdelem_get_user_data(grpc_mdelem md, void (*destroy_func)(void*)) {
459   switch (GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE(md)) {
460     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_EXTERNAL:
461     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_ALLOCATED:
462       return nullptr;
463     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_STATIC:
464       return (void*)grpc_static_mdelem_user_data[GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(md) -
465                                                  grpc_static_mdelem_table];
466     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_INTERNED: {
467       interned_metadata* im =
468           reinterpret_cast<interned_metadata*> GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(md);
469       void* result;
470       if (gpr_atm_acq_load(&im->destroy_user_data) == (gpr_atm)destroy_func) {
471         return (void*)gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&im->user_data);
472       } else {
473         return nullptr;
474       }
475       return result;
476     }
477   }
478   GPR_UNREACHABLE_CODE(return nullptr);
479 }
480 
grpc_mdelem_set_user_data(grpc_mdelem md,void (* destroy_func)(void *),void * user_data)481 void* grpc_mdelem_set_user_data(grpc_mdelem md, void (*destroy_func)(void*),
482                                 void* user_data) {
483   switch (GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE(md)) {
484     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_EXTERNAL:
485     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_ALLOCATED:
486       destroy_func(user_data);
487       return nullptr;
488     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_STATIC:
489       destroy_func(user_data);
490       return (void*)grpc_static_mdelem_user_data[GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(md) -
491                                                  grpc_static_mdelem_table];
492     case GRPC_MDELEM_STORAGE_INTERNED: {
493       interned_metadata* im =
494           reinterpret_cast<interned_metadata*> GRPC_MDELEM_DATA(md);
495       GPR_ASSERT(!is_mdelem_static(md));
496       GPR_ASSERT((user_data == nullptr) == (destroy_func == nullptr));
497       gpr_mu_lock(&im->mu_user_data);
498       if (gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&im->destroy_user_data)) {
499         /* user data can only be set once */
500         gpr_mu_unlock(&im->mu_user_data);
501         if (destroy_func != nullptr) {
502           destroy_func(user_data);
503         }
504         return (void*)gpr_atm_no_barrier_load(&im->user_data);
505       }
506       gpr_atm_no_barrier_store(&im->user_data, (gpr_atm)user_data);
507       gpr_atm_rel_store(&im->destroy_user_data, (gpr_atm)destroy_func);
508       gpr_mu_unlock(&im->mu_user_data);
509       return user_data;
510     }
511   }
512   GPR_UNREACHABLE_CODE(return nullptr);
513 }
514 
grpc_mdelem_eq(grpc_mdelem a,grpc_mdelem b)515 bool grpc_mdelem_eq(grpc_mdelem a, grpc_mdelem b) {
516   if (a.payload == b.payload) return true;
517   if (GRPC_MDELEM_IS_INTERNED(a) && GRPC_MDELEM_IS_INTERNED(b)) return false;
518   if (GRPC_MDISNULL(a) || GRPC_MDISNULL(b)) return false;
519   return grpc_slice_eq(GRPC_MDKEY(a), GRPC_MDKEY(b)) &&
520          grpc_slice_eq(GRPC_MDVALUE(a), GRPC_MDVALUE(b));
521 }
522