• Home
  • Line#
  • Scopes#
  • Navigate#
  • Raw
  • Download
1 /*
2  * Copyright 2018 Google Inc.
3  *
4  * Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
5  * found in the LICENSE file.
6  */
7 
8 #include "tools/skqp/src/skqp.h"
9 
10 #include "gm/gm.h"
11 #include "include/core/SkFontStyle.h"
12 #include "include/core/SkGraphics.h"
13 #include "include/core/SkStream.h"
14 #include "include/core/SkSurface.h"
15 #include "include/encode/SkPngEncoder.h"
16 #include "include/gpu/GrContextOptions.h"
17 #include "include/gpu/GrDirectContext.h"
18 #include "include/private/SkImageInfoPriv.h"
19 #include "src/core/SkFontMgrPriv.h"
20 #include "src/core/SkOSFile.h"
21 #include "src/core/SkStreamPriv.h"
22 #include "src/utils/SkOSPath.h"
23 #include "tests/Test.h"
24 #include "tools/fonts/TestFontMgr.h"
25 #ifdef SK_GL
26 #include "tools/gpu/gl/GLTestContext.h"
27 #endif
28 #ifdef SK_VULKAN
29 #include "tools/gpu/vk/VkTestContext.h"
30 #endif
31 
32 #include <limits.h>
33 #include <algorithm>
34 #include <cinttypes>
35 #include <sstream>
36 
37 #include "tools/skqp/src/skqp_model.h"
38 
39 #define IMAGES_DIRECTORY_PATH "images"
40 #define PATH_MAX_PNG "max.png"
41 #define PATH_MIN_PNG "min.png"
42 #define PATH_IMG_PNG "image.png"
43 #define PATH_ERR_PNG "errors.png"
44 #define PATH_MODEL "model"
45 
46 static constexpr char kRenderTestCSVReport[] = "out.csv";
47 static constexpr char kRenderTestReportPath[] = "report.html";
48 static constexpr char kDefaultRenderTestsPath[] = "skqp/rendertests.txt";
49 static constexpr char kUnitTestReportPath[] = "unit_tests.txt";
50 static constexpr char kUnitTestsPath[]   = "skqp/unittests.txt";
51 
52 // Kind of like Python's readlines(), but without any allocation.
53 // Calls f() on each line.
54 // F is [](const char*, size_t) -> void
55 template <typename F>
readlines(const void * data,size_t size,F f)56 static void readlines(const void* data, size_t size, F f) {
57     const char* start = (const char*)data;
58     const char* end = start + size;
59     const char* ptr = start;
60     while (ptr < end) {
61         while (*ptr++ != '\n' && ptr < end) {}
62         size_t len = ptr - start;
63         f(start, len);
64         start = ptr;
65     }
66 }
67 
get_unit_tests(SkQPAssetManager * mgr,std::vector<SkQP::UnitTest> * unitTests)68 static void get_unit_tests(SkQPAssetManager* mgr, std::vector<SkQP::UnitTest>* unitTests) {
69     std::unordered_set<std::string> testset;
70     auto insert = [&testset](const char* s, size_t l) {
71         SkASSERT(l > 1) ;
72         if (l > 0 && s[l - 1] == '\n') {  // strip line endings.
73             --l;
74         }
75         if (l > 0) {  // only add non-empty strings.
76             testset.insert(std::string(s, l));
77         }
78     };
79     if (sk_sp<SkData> dat = mgr->open(kUnitTestsPath)) {
80         readlines(dat->data(), dat->size(), insert);
81     }
82     for (const skiatest::Test& test : skiatest::TestRegistry::Range()) {
83         if ((testset.empty() || testset.count(std::string(test.fName)) > 0) && test.fNeedsGpu) {
84             unitTests->push_back(&test);
85         }
86     }
87     auto lt = [](SkQP::UnitTest u, SkQP::UnitTest v) { return strcmp(u->fName, v->fName) < 0; };
88     std::sort(unitTests->begin(), unitTests->end(), lt);
89 }
90 
get_render_tests(SkQPAssetManager * mgr,const char * renderTestsIn,std::vector<SkQP::GMFactory> * gmlist,std::unordered_map<std::string,int64_t> * gmThresholds)91 static void get_render_tests(SkQPAssetManager* mgr,
92                              const char *renderTestsIn,
93                              std::vector<SkQP::GMFactory>* gmlist,
94                              std::unordered_map<std::string, int64_t>* gmThresholds) {
95     // Runs all render tests if the |renderTests| file can't be found or is empty.
96     const char *renderTests = (renderTestsIn && renderTestsIn[0]) ?
97         renderTestsIn : kDefaultRenderTestsPath;
98     auto insert = [gmThresholds](const char* s, size_t l) {
99         SkASSERT(l > 1) ;
100         if (l > 0 && s[l - 1] == '\n') {  // strip line endings.
101             --l;
102         }
103         if (l == 0) {
104             return;
105         }
106         const char* end = s + l;
107         const char* ptr = s;
108         constexpr char kDelimeter = ',';
109         while (ptr < end && *ptr != kDelimeter) { ++ptr; }
110         if (ptr + 1 >= end) {
111             SkASSERT(false);  // missing delimeter
112             return;
113         }
114         std::string key(s, ptr - s);
115         ++ptr;  // skip delimeter
116         std::string number(ptr, end - ptr);  // null-terminated copy.
117         int64_t value = 0;
118         if (1 != sscanf(number.c_str(), "%" SCNd64 , &value)) {
119             SkASSERT(false);  // Not a number
120             return;
121         }
122         gmThresholds->insert({std::move(key), value});  // (*gmThresholds)[s] = value;
123     };
124     if (sk_sp<SkData> dat = mgr->open(renderTests)) {
125         readlines(dat->data(), dat->size(), insert);
126     }
127     using GmAndName = std::pair<SkQP::GMFactory, std::string>;
128     std::vector<GmAndName> gmsWithNames;
129     for (skiagm::GMFactory f : skiagm::GMRegistry::Range()) {
130         std::string name = SkQP::GetGMName(f);
131         if ((gmThresholds->empty() || gmThresholds->count(name) > 0)) {
132             gmsWithNames.push_back(std::make_pair(f, std::move(name)));
133         }
134     }
135     std::sort(gmsWithNames.begin(), gmsWithNames.end(),
136               [](GmAndName u, GmAndName v) { return u.second < v.second; });
137     gmlist->reserve(gmsWithNames.size());
138     for (const GmAndName& gmn : gmsWithNames) {
139         gmlist->push_back(gmn.first);
140     }
141 }
142 
make_test_context(SkQP::SkiaBackend backend)143 static std::unique_ptr<sk_gpu_test::TestContext> make_test_context(SkQP::SkiaBackend backend) {
144     using U = std::unique_ptr<sk_gpu_test::TestContext>;
145     switch (backend) {
146 // TODO(halcanary): Fuchsia will have SK_SUPPORT_GPU and SK_VULKAN, but *not* SK_GL.
147 #ifdef SK_GL
148         case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGL:
149             return U(sk_gpu_test::CreatePlatformGLTestContext(kGL_GrGLStandard, nullptr));
150         case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGLES:
151             return U(sk_gpu_test::CreatePlatformGLTestContext(kGLES_GrGLStandard, nullptr));
152 #endif
153 #ifdef SK_VULKAN
154         case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kVulkan:
155             return U(sk_gpu_test::CreatePlatformVkTestContext(nullptr));
156 #endif
157         default:
158             return nullptr;
159     }
160 }
161 
context_options(skiagm::GM * gm=nullptr)162 static GrContextOptions context_options(skiagm::GM* gm = nullptr) {
163     GrContextOptions grContextOptions;
164     grContextOptions.fAllowPathMaskCaching = true;
165     grContextOptions.fDisableDriverCorrectnessWorkarounds = true;
166     if (gm) {
167         gm->modifyGrContextOptions(&grContextOptions);
168     }
169     return grContextOptions;
170 }
171 
get_backends()172 static std::vector<SkQP::SkiaBackend> get_backends() {
173     std::vector<SkQP::SkiaBackend> result;
174     SkQP::SkiaBackend backends[] = {
175         #ifdef SK_GL
176         #ifndef SK_BUILD_FOR_ANDROID
177         SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGL,  // Used for testing on desktop machines.
178         #endif
179         SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGLES,
180         #endif  // SK_GL
181         #ifdef SK_VULKAN
182         SkQP::SkiaBackend::kVulkan,
183         #endif
184     };
185     for (SkQP::SkiaBackend backend : backends) {
186         std::unique_ptr<sk_gpu_test::TestContext> testCtx = make_test_context(backend);
187         if (testCtx) {
188             testCtx->makeCurrent();
189             if (nullptr != testCtx->makeContext(context_options())) {
190                 result.push_back(backend);
191             }
192         }
193     }
194     SkASSERT_RELEASE(result.size() > 0);
195     return result;
196 }
197 
print_backend_info(const char * dstPath,const std::vector<SkQP::SkiaBackend> & backends)198 static void print_backend_info(const char* dstPath,
199                                const std::vector<SkQP::SkiaBackend>& backends) {
200 #ifdef SK_ENABLE_DUMP_GPU
201     SkFILEWStream out(dstPath);
202     out.writeText("[\n");
203     for (SkQP::SkiaBackend backend : backends) {
204         if (std::unique_ptr<sk_gpu_test::TestContext> testCtx = make_test_context(backend)) {
205             testCtx->makeCurrent();
206             if (sk_sp<GrDirectContext> ctx = testCtx->makeContext(context_options())) {
207                 SkString info = ctx->dump();
208                 // remove null
209                 out.write(info.c_str(), info.size());
210                 out.writeText(",\n");
211             }
212         }
213     }
214     out.writeText("]\n");
215 #endif
216 }
217 
encode_png(const SkBitmap & src,const std::string & dst)218 static void encode_png(const SkBitmap& src, const std::string& dst) {
219     SkFILEWStream wStream(dst.c_str());
220     SkPngEncoder::Options options;
221     bool success = wStream.isValid() && SkPngEncoder::Encode(&wStream, src.pixmap(), options);
222     SkASSERT_RELEASE(success);
223 }
224 
write_to_file(const sk_sp<SkData> & src,const std::string & dst)225 static void write_to_file(const sk_sp<SkData>& src, const std::string& dst) {
226     SkFILEWStream wStream(dst.c_str());
227     bool success = wStream.isValid() && wStream.write(src->data(), src->size());
228     SkASSERT_RELEASE(success);
229 }
230 
231 ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
232 
GetBackendName(SkQP::SkiaBackend b)233 const char* SkQP::GetBackendName(SkQP::SkiaBackend b) {
234     switch (b) {
235         case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGL:     return "gl";
236         case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGLES:   return "gles";
237         case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kVulkan: return "vk";
238     }
239     return "";
240 }
241 
GetGMName(SkQP::GMFactory f)242 std::string SkQP::GetGMName(SkQP::GMFactory f) {
243     std::unique_ptr<skiagm::GM> gm(f ? f() : nullptr);
244     return std::string(gm ? gm->getName() : "");
245 }
246 
GetUnitTestName(SkQP::UnitTest t)247 const char* SkQP::GetUnitTestName(SkQP::UnitTest t) { return t->fName; }
248 
SkQP()249 SkQP::SkQP() {}
250 
~SkQP()251 SkQP::~SkQP() {}
252 
init(SkQPAssetManager * am,const char * renderTests,const char * reportDirectory)253 void SkQP::init(SkQPAssetManager* am, const char* renderTests, const char* reportDirectory) {
254     SkASSERT_RELEASE(!fAssetManager);
255     SkASSERT_RELEASE(am);
256     fAssetManager = am;
257     fReportDirectory = reportDirectory;
258 
259     SkGraphics::Init();
260     gSkFontMgr_DefaultFactory = &ToolUtils::MakePortableFontMgr;
261 
262     get_render_tests(fAssetManager, renderTests, &fGMs, &fGMThresholds);
263     /* If the file "skqp/unittests.txt" does not exist or is empty, run all gpu
264        unit tests.  Otherwise only run tests mentioned in that file.  */
265     get_unit_tests(fAssetManager, &fUnitTests);
266     fSupportedBackends = get_backends();
267 
268     print_backend_info((fReportDirectory + "/grdump.txt").c_str(), fSupportedBackends);
269 }
270 
evaluateGM(SkQP::SkiaBackend backend,SkQP::GMFactory gmFact)271 std::tuple<SkQP::RenderOutcome, std::string> SkQP::evaluateGM(SkQP::SkiaBackend backend,
272                                                               SkQP::GMFactory gmFact) {
273     SkASSERT_RELEASE(fAssetManager);
274     static constexpr SkQP::RenderOutcome kError = {INT_MAX, INT_MAX, INT64_MAX};
275     static constexpr SkQP::RenderOutcome kPass = {0, 0, 0};
276 
277     std::unique_ptr<sk_gpu_test::TestContext> testCtx = make_test_context(backend);
278     if (!testCtx) {
279         return std::make_tuple(kError, "Skia Failure: test context");
280     }
281     testCtx->makeCurrent();
282 
283     SkASSERT(gmFact);
284     std::unique_ptr<skiagm::GM> gm(gmFact());
285     SkASSERT(gm);
286     const char* const name = gm->getName();
287     const SkISize size = gm->getISize();
288     const int w = size.width();
289     const int h = size.height();
290     const SkImageInfo info =
291         SkImageInfo::Make(w, h, skqp::kColorType, kPremul_SkAlphaType, nullptr);
292     const SkSurfaceProps props(0, kRGB_H_SkPixelGeometry);
293 
294     sk_sp<SkSurface> surf = SkSurface::MakeRenderTarget(
295             testCtx->makeContext(context_options(gm.get())).get(),
296             SkBudgeted::kNo, info, 0, &props);
297     if (!surf) {
298         return std::make_tuple(kError, "Skia Failure: gr-context");
299     }
300     gm->draw(surf->getCanvas());
301 
302     SkBitmap image;
303     image.allocPixels(SkImageInfo::Make(w, h, skqp::kColorType, skqp::kAlphaType));
304 
305     // SkColorTypeBytesPerPixel should be constexpr, but is not.
306     SkASSERT(SkColorTypeBytesPerPixel(skqp::kColorType) == sizeof(uint32_t));
307     // Call readPixels because we need to compare pixels.
308     if (!surf->readPixels(image.pixmap(), 0, 0)) {
309         return std::make_tuple(kError, "Skia Failure: read pixels");
310     }
311     int64_t passingThreshold = fGMThresholds.empty() ? -1 : fGMThresholds[std::string(name)];
312 
313     if (-1 == passingThreshold) {
314         return std::make_tuple(kPass, "");
315     }
316     skqp::ModelResult modelResult =
317         skqp::CheckAgainstModel(name, image.pixmap(), fAssetManager);
318 
319     if (!modelResult.fErrorString.empty()) {
320         return std::make_tuple(kError, std::move(modelResult.fErrorString));
321     }
322     fRenderResults.push_back(SkQP::RenderResult{backend, gmFact, modelResult.fOutcome});
323     if (modelResult.fOutcome.fMaxError <= passingThreshold) {
324         return std::make_tuple(kPass, "");
325     }
326     std::string imagesDirectory = fReportDirectory + "/" IMAGES_DIRECTORY_PATH;
327     if (!sk_mkdir(imagesDirectory.c_str())) {
328         SkDebugf("ERROR: sk_mkdir('%s');\n", imagesDirectory.c_str());
329         return std::make_tuple(modelResult.fOutcome, "");
330     }
331     std::ostringstream tmp;
332     tmp << imagesDirectory << '/' << SkQP::GetBackendName(backend) << '_' << name << '_';
333     std::string imagesPathPrefix1 = tmp.str();
334     tmp = std::ostringstream();
335     tmp << imagesDirectory << '/' << PATH_MODEL << '_' << name << '_';
336     std::string imagesPathPrefix2 = tmp.str();
337     encode_png(image,                  imagesPathPrefix1 + PATH_IMG_PNG);
338     encode_png(modelResult.fErrors,    imagesPathPrefix1 + PATH_ERR_PNG);
339     write_to_file(modelResult.fMaxPng, imagesPathPrefix2 + PATH_MAX_PNG);
340     write_to_file(modelResult.fMinPng, imagesPathPrefix2 + PATH_MIN_PNG);
341     return std::make_tuple(modelResult.fOutcome, "");
342 }
343 
executeTest(SkQP::UnitTest test)344 std::vector<std::string> SkQP::executeTest(SkQP::UnitTest test) {
345     SkASSERT_RELEASE(fAssetManager);
346     struct : public skiatest::Reporter {
347         std::vector<std::string> fErrors;
348         void reportFailed(const skiatest::Failure& failure) override {
349             SkString desc = failure.toString();
350             fErrors.push_back(std::string(desc.c_str(), desc.size()));
351         }
352     } r;
353     GrContextOptions options;
354     options.fDisableDriverCorrectnessWorkarounds = true;
355     if (test->fContextOptionsProc) {
356         test->fContextOptionsProc(&options);
357     }
358     test->fProc(&r, options);
359     fUnitTestResults.push_back(UnitTestResult{test, r.fErrors});
360     return r.fErrors;
361 }
362 
363 ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
364 
365 static constexpr char kDocHead[] =
366     "<!doctype html>\n"
367     "<html lang=\"en\">\n"
368     "<head>\n"
369     "<meta charset=\"UTF-8\">\n"
370     "<title>SkQP Report</title>\n"
371     "<style>\n"
372     "img { max-width:48%; border:1px green solid;\n"
373     "      image-rendering: pixelated;\n"
374     "      background-image:url('"
375     "AAANSUhEUgAAABAAAAAQCAAAAAA6mKC9AAAAAXNSR0IArs4c6QAAAAJiS0dEAP+H"
376     "j8y/AAAACXBIWXMAAA7DAAAOwwHHb6hkAAAAB3RJTUUH3gUBEi4DGRAQYgAAAB1J"
377     "REFUGNNjfMoAAVJQmokBDdBHgPE/lPFsYN0BABdaAwN6tehMAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC"
378     "'); }\n"
379     "</style>\n"
380     "<script>\n"
381     "function ce(t) { return document.createElement(t); }\n"
382     "function ct(n) { return document.createTextNode(n); }\n"
383     "function ac(u,v) { return u.appendChild(v); }\n"
384     "function br(u) { ac(u, ce(\"br\")); }\n"
385     "function ma(s, c) { var a = ce(\"a\"); a.href = s; ac(a, c); return a; }\n"
386     "function f(backend, gm, e1, e2, e3) {\n"
387     "  var b = ce(\"div\");\n"
388     "  var x = ce(\"h2\");\n"
389     "  var t = backend + \"_\" + gm;\n"
390     "  ac(x, ct(t));\n"
391     "  ac(b, x);\n"
392     "  ac(b, ct(\"backend: \" + backend));\n"
393     "  br(b);\n"
394     "  ac(b, ct(\"gm name: \" + gm));\n"
395     "  br(b);\n"
396     "  ac(b, ct(\"maximum error: \" + e1));\n"
397     "  br(b);\n"
398     "  ac(b, ct(\"bad pixel counts: \" + e2));\n"
399     "  br(b);\n"
400     "  ac(b, ct(\"total error: \" + e3));\n"
401     "  br(b);\n"
402     "  var q = \"" IMAGES_DIRECTORY_PATH "/\" + backend + \"_\" + gm + \"_\";\n"
403     "  var p = \"" IMAGES_DIRECTORY_PATH "/"   PATH_MODEL  "_\" + gm + \"_\";\n"
404     "  var i = ce(\"img\");\n"
405     "  i.src = q + \"" PATH_IMG_PNG "\";\n"
406     "  i.alt = \"img\";\n"
407     "  ac(b, ma(i.src, i));\n"
408     "  i = ce(\"img\");\n"
409     "  i.src = q + \"" PATH_ERR_PNG "\";\n"
410     "  i.alt = \"err\";\n"
411     "  ac(b, ma(i.src, i));\n"
412     "  br(b);\n"
413     "  ac(b, ct(\"Expectation: \"));\n"
414     "  ac(b, ma(p + \"" PATH_MAX_PNG "\", ct(\"max\")));\n"
415     "  ac(b, ct(\" | \"));\n"
416     "  ac(b, ma(p + \"" PATH_MIN_PNG "\", ct(\"min\")));\n"
417     "  ac(b, ce(\"hr\"));\n"
418     "  b.id = backend + \":\" + gm;\n"
419     "  ac(document.body, b);\n"
420     "  l = ce(\"li\");\n"
421     "  ac(l, ct(\"[\" + e3 + \"] \"));\n"
422     "  ac(l, ma(\"#\" + backend +\":\"+ gm , ct(t)));\n"
423     "  ac(document.getElementById(\"toc\"), l);\n"
424     "}\n"
425     "function main() {\n";
426 
427 static constexpr char kDocMiddle[] =
428     "}\n"
429     "</script>\n"
430     "</head>\n"
431     "<body onload=\"main()\">\n"
432     "<h1>SkQP Report</h1>\n";
433 
434 static constexpr char kDocTail[] =
435     "<ul id=\"toc\"></ul>\n"
436     "<hr>\n"
437     "<p>Left image: test result<br>\n"
438     "Right image: errors (white = no error, black = smallest error, red = biggest error; "
439     "other errors are a color between black and red.)</p>\n"
440     "<hr>\n"
441     "</body>\n"
442     "</html>\n";
443 
444 template <typename T>
write(SkWStream * wStream,const T & text)445 inline void write(SkWStream* wStream, const T& text) {
446     wStream->write(text.c_str(), text.size());
447 }
448 
makeReport()449 void SkQP::makeReport() {
450     SkASSERT_RELEASE(fAssetManager);
451     int glesErrorCount = 0, vkErrorCount = 0, gles = 0, vk = 0;
452 
453     if (!sk_isdir(fReportDirectory.c_str())) {
454         SkDebugf("Report destination does not exist: '%s'\n", fReportDirectory.c_str());
455         return;
456     }
457     SkFILEWStream csvOut(SkOSPath::Join(fReportDirectory.c_str(), kRenderTestCSVReport).c_str());
458     SkFILEWStream htmOut(SkOSPath::Join(fReportDirectory.c_str(), kRenderTestReportPath).c_str());
459     SkASSERT_RELEASE(csvOut.isValid() && htmOut.isValid());
460     htmOut.writeText(kDocHead);
461     for (const SkQP::RenderResult& run : fRenderResults) {
462         switch (run.fBackend) {
463             case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGLES: ++gles; break;
464             case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kVulkan: ++vk; break;
465             default: break;
466         }
467         const char* backendName = SkQP::GetBackendName(run.fBackend);
468         std::string gmName = SkQP::GetGMName(run.fGM);
469         const SkQP::RenderOutcome& outcome = run.fOutcome;
470         auto str = SkStringPrintf("\"%s\",\"%s\",%d,%d,%" PRId64, backendName, gmName.c_str(),
471                                   outcome.fMaxError, outcome.fBadPixelCount, outcome.fTotalError);
472         write(&csvOut, SkStringPrintf("%s\n", str.c_str()));
473 
474         int64_t passingThreshold = fGMThresholds.empty() ? 0 : fGMThresholds[gmName];
475         if (passingThreshold == -1 || outcome.fMaxError <= passingThreshold) {
476             continue;
477         }
478         write(&htmOut, SkStringPrintf("  f(%s);\n", str.c_str()));
479         switch (run.fBackend) {
480             case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kGLES: ++glesErrorCount; break;
481             case SkQP::SkiaBackend::kVulkan: ++vkErrorCount; break;
482             default: break;
483         }
484     }
485     htmOut.writeText(kDocMiddle);
486     write(&htmOut, SkStringPrintf("<p>gles errors: %d (of %d)</br>\n"
487                                   "vk errors: %d (of %d)</p>\n",
488                                   glesErrorCount, gles, vkErrorCount, vk));
489     htmOut.writeText(kDocTail);
490     SkFILEWStream unitOut(SkOSPath::Join(fReportDirectory.c_str(), kUnitTestReportPath).c_str());
491     SkASSERT_RELEASE(unitOut.isValid());
492     for (const SkQP::UnitTestResult& result : fUnitTestResults) {
493         unitOut.writeText(GetUnitTestName(result.fUnitTest));
494         if (result.fErrors.empty()) {
495             unitOut.writeText(" PASSED\n* * *\n");
496         } else {
497             write(&unitOut, SkStringPrintf(" FAILED (%zu errors)\n", result.fErrors.size()));
498             for (const std::string& err : result.fErrors) {
499                 write(&unitOut, err);
500                 unitOut.newline();
501             }
502             unitOut.writeText("* * *\n");
503         }
504     }
505 }
506