• Home
  • Line#
  • Scopes#
  • Navigate#
  • Raw
  • Download
1 // Copyright 2012 The Chromium Authors
2 // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
3 // found in the LICENSE file.
4 
5 #ifndef BASE_VALUES_H_
6 #define BASE_VALUES_H_
7 
8 #include <stddef.h>
9 #include <stdint.h>
10 
11 #include <array>
12 #include <initializer_list>
13 #include <iosfwd>
14 #include <iterator>
15 #include <memory>
16 #include <string>
17 #include <utility>
18 #include <vector>
19 
20 #include "base/base_export.h"
21 #include "base/bit_cast.h"
22 #include "base/compiler_specific.h"
23 #include "base/containers/checked_iterators.h"
24 #include "base/containers/cxx20_erase_vector.h"
25 #include "base/containers/flat_map.h"
26 #include "base/containers/span.h"
27 #include "base/memory/raw_ref.h"
28 #include "base/strings/string_piece.h"
29 #include "base/trace_event/base_tracing_forward.h"
30 #include "base/value_iterators.h"
31 #include "third_party/abseil-cpp/absl/types/optional.h"
32 #include "third_party/abseil-cpp/absl/types/variant.h"
33 
34 namespace base {
35 
36 // The `Value` class is a variant type can hold one of the following types:
37 // - null
38 // - bool
39 // - int
40 // - double
41 // - string (internally UTF8-encoded)
42 // - binary data (i.e. a blob)
43 // - dictionary of string keys to `Value`s
44 // - list of `Value`s
45 //
46 // With the exception of binary blobs, `Value` is intended to be the C++ version
47 // of data types that can be represented in JSON.
48 //
49 // Warning: blob support may be removed in the future.
50 //
51 // ## Usage
52 //
53 // Do not use `Value` if a more specific type would be more appropriate.  For
54 // example, a function that only accepts dictionary values should have a
55 // `base::Value::Dict` parameter, not a `base::Value` parameter.
56 //
57 // Construction:
58 //
59 // `Value` is directly constructible from `bool`, `int`, `double`, binary blobs
60 // (`std::vector<uint8_t>`), `base::StringPiece`, `base::StringPiece16`,
61 // `Value::Dict`, and `Value::List`.
62 //
63 // Copying:
64 //
65 // `Value` does not support C++ copy semantics to make it harder to accidentally
66 // copy large values. Instead, use `Clone()` to manually create a deep copy.
67 //
68 // Reading:
69 //
70 // `GetBool()`, GetInt()`, et cetera `CHECK()` that the `Value` has the correct
71 // subtype before returning the contained value. `bool`, `int`, `double` are
72 // returned by value. Binary blobs, `std::string`, `Value::Dict`, `Value::List`
73 // are returned by reference.
74 //
75 // `GetIfBool()`, `GetIfInt()`, et cetera return `absl::nullopt`/`nullptr` if
76 // the `Value` does not have the correct subtype; otherwise, returns the value
77 // wrapped in an `absl::optional` (for `bool`, `int`, `double`) or by pointer
78 // (for binary blobs, `std::string`, `Value::Dict`, `Value::List`).
79 //
80 // Note: both `GetDouble()` and `GetIfDouble()` still return a non-null result
81 // when the subtype is `Value::Type::INT`. In that case, the stored value is
82 // coerced to a double before being returned.
83 //
84 // Assignment:
85 //
86 // It is not possible to directly assign `bool`, `int`, et cetera to a `Value`.
87 // Instead, wrap the underlying type in `Value` before assigning.
88 //
89 // ## Dictionaries and Lists
90 //
91 // `Value` provides the `Value::Dict` and `Value::List` container types for
92 // working with dictionaries and lists of values respectively, rather than
93 // exposing the underlying container types directly. This allows the types to
94 // provide convenient helpers for dictionaries and lists, as well as giving
95 // greater flexibility for changing implementation details in the future.
96 //
97 // Both container types support enough STL-isms to be usable in range-based for
98 // loops and generic operations such as those from <algorithm>.
99 //
100 // Dictionaries support:
101 // - `empty()`, `size()`, `begin()`, `end()`, `cbegin()`, `cend()`,
102 //       `contains()`, `clear()`, `erase()`: Identical to the STL container
103 //       equivalents, with additional safety checks, e.g. iterators will
104 //       `CHECK()` if `end()` is dereferenced.
105 //
106 // - `Clone()`: Create a deep copy.
107 // - `Merge()`: Merge another dictionary into this dictionary.
108 // - `Find()`: Find a value by `StringPiece` key, returning nullptr if the key
109 //       is not present.
110 // - `FindBool()`, `FindInt()`, ...: Similar to `Find()`, but ensures that the
111 //       `Value` also has the correct subtype. Same return semantics as
112 //       `GetIfBool()`, `GetIfInt()`, et cetera, returning `absl::nullopt` or
113 //       `nullptr` if the key is not present or the value has the wrong subtype.
114 // - `Set()`: Associate a value with a `StringPiece` key. Accepts `Value` or any
115 //       of the subtypes that `Value` can hold.
116 // - `Remove()`: Remove the key from this dictionary, if present.
117 // - `Extract()`: If the key is present in the dictionary, removes the key from
118 //       the dictionary and transfers ownership of `Value` to the caller.
119 //       Otherwise, returns `absl::nullopt`.
120 //
121 // Dictionaries also support an additional set of helper methods that operate on
122 // "paths": `FindByDottedPath()`, `SetByDottedPath()`, `RemoveByDottedPath()`,
123 // and `ExtractByDottedPath()`. Dotted paths are a convenience method of naming
124 // intermediate nested dictionaries, separating the components of the path using
125 // '.' characters. For example, finding a string path on a `Value::Dict` using
126 // the dotted path:
127 //
128 //   "aaa.bbb.ccc"
129 //
130 // Will first look for a `Value::Type::DICT` associated with the key "aaa", then
131 // another `Value::Type::DICT` under the "aaa" dict associated with the
132 // key "bbb", and then a `Value::Type::STRING` under the "bbb" dict associated
133 // with the key "ccc".
134 //
135 // If a path only has one component (i.e. has no dots), please use the regular,
136 // non-path APIs.
137 //
138 // Lists support:
139 // - `empty()`, `size()`, `begin()`, `end()`, `cbegin()`, `cend()`,
140 //       `rbegin()`, `rend()`, `front()`, `back()`, `reserve()`, `operator[]`,
141 //       `clear()`, `erase()`: Identical to the STL container equivalents, with
142 //       additional safety checks, e.g. `operator[]` will `CHECK()` if the index
143 //       is out of range.
144 // - `Clone()`: Create a deep copy.
145 // - `Append()`: Append a value to the end of the list. Accepts `Value` or any
146 //       of the subtypes that `Value` can hold.
147 // - `Insert()`: Insert a `Value` at a specified point in the list.
148 // - `EraseValue()`: Erases all matching `Value`s from the list.
149 // - `EraseIf()`: Erase all `Value`s matching an arbitrary predicate from the
150 //       list.
151 class BASE_EXPORT GSL_OWNER Value {
152  public:
153   using BlobStorage = std::vector<uint8_t>;
154 
155   class Dict;
156   class List;
157 
158   enum class Type : unsigned char {
159     NONE = 0,
160     BOOLEAN,
161     INTEGER,
162     DOUBLE,
163     STRING,
164     BINARY,
165     DICT,
166     LIST,
167     // Note: Do not add more types. See the file-level comment above for why.
168   };
169 
170   // Adaptors for converting from the old way to the new way and vice versa.
171   static Value FromUniquePtrValue(std::unique_ptr<Value> val);
172   static std::unique_ptr<Value> ToUniquePtrValue(Value val);
173 
174   Value() noexcept;
175 
176   Value(Value&&) noexcept;
177   Value& operator=(Value&&) noexcept;
178 
179   // Deleted to prevent accidental copying.
180   Value(const Value&) = delete;
181   Value& operator=(const Value&) = delete;
182 
183   // Creates a deep copy of this value.
184   Value Clone() const;
185 
186   // Creates a `Value` of `type`. The data of the corresponding type will be
187   // default constructed.
188   explicit Value(Type type);
189 
190   // Constructor for `Value::Type::BOOLEAN`.
191   explicit Value(bool value);
192 
193   // Prevent pointers from implicitly converting to bool. Another way to write
194   // this would be to template the bool constructor and use SFINAE to only allow
195   // use if `std::is_same_v<T, bool>` is true, but this has surprising behavior
196   // with range-based for loops over a `std::vector<bool>` (which will
197   // unintuitively match the int overload instead).
198   //
199   // The `const` is load-bearing; otherwise, a `char*` argument would prefer the
200   // deleted overload due to requiring a qualification conversion.
201   template <typename T>
202   explicit Value(const T*) = delete;
203 
204   // Constructor for `Value::Type::INT`.
205   explicit Value(int value);
206 
207   // Constructor for `Value::Type::DOUBLE`.
208   explicit Value(double value);
209 
210   // Constructors for `Value::Type::STRING`.
211   explicit Value(StringPiece value);
212   explicit Value(StringPiece16 value);
213   // `char*` and `char16_t*` are needed to provide a more specific overload than
214   // the deleted `const T*` overload above.
215   explicit Value(const char* value);
216   explicit Value(const char16_t* value);
217   // `std::string&&` allows for efficient move construction.
218   explicit Value(std::string&& value) noexcept;
219 
220   // Constructors for `Value::Type::BINARY`.
221   explicit Value(const std::vector<char>& value);
222   explicit Value(base::span<const uint8_t> value);
223   explicit Value(BlobStorage&& value) noexcept;
224 
225   // Constructor for `Value::Type::DICT`.
226   explicit Value(Dict&& value) noexcept;
227 
228   // Constructor for `Value::Type::LIST`.
229   explicit Value(List&& value) noexcept;
230 
231   ~Value();
232 
233   // Returns the name for a given `type`.
234   static const char* GetTypeName(Type type);
235 
236   // Returns the type of the value stored by the current Value object.
type()237   Type type() const { return static_cast<Type>(data_.index()); }
238 
239   // Returns true if the current object represents a given type.
is_none()240   bool is_none() const { return type() == Type::NONE; }
is_bool()241   bool is_bool() const { return type() == Type::BOOLEAN; }
is_int()242   bool is_int() const { return type() == Type::INTEGER; }
is_double()243   bool is_double() const { return type() == Type::DOUBLE; }
is_string()244   bool is_string() const { return type() == Type::STRING; }
is_blob()245   bool is_blob() const { return type() == Type::BINARY; }
is_dict()246   bool is_dict() const { return type() == Type::DICT; }
is_list()247   bool is_list() const { return type() == Type::LIST; }
248 
249   // Returns the stored data if the type matches, or `absl::nullopt`/`nullptr`
250   // otherwise. `bool`, `int`, and `double` are returned in a wrapped
251   // `absl::optional`; blobs, `Value::Dict`, and `Value::List` are returned by
252   // pointer.
253   absl::optional<bool> GetIfBool() const;
254   absl::optional<int> GetIfInt() const;
255   // Returns a non-null value for both `Value::Type::DOUBLE` and
256   // `Value::Type::INT`, converting the latter to a double.
257   absl::optional<double> GetIfDouble() const;
258   const std::string* GetIfString() const;
259   std::string* GetIfString();
260   const BlobStorage* GetIfBlob() const;
261   const Dict* GetIfDict() const;
262   Dict* GetIfDict();
263   const List* GetIfList() const;
264   List* GetIfList();
265 
266   // Similar to the `GetIf...()` variants above, but fails with a `CHECK()` on a
267   // type mismatch. `bool`, `int`, and `double` are returned by value; blobs,
268   // `Value::Dict`, and `Value::List` are returned by reference.
269   bool GetBool() const;
270   int GetInt() const;
271   // Returns a value for both `Value::Type::DOUBLE` and `Value::Type::INT`,
272   // converting the latter to a double.
273   double GetDouble() const;
274   const std::string& GetString() const;
275   std::string& GetString();
276   const BlobStorage& GetBlob() const;
277   const Dict& GetDict() const;
278   Dict& GetDict();
279   const List& GetList() const;
280   List& GetList();
281 
282   // Transfers ownership of the underlying value. Similarly to `Get...()`
283   // variants above, fails with a `CHECK()` on a type mismatch. After
284   // transferring the ownership `*this` is in a valid, but unspecified, state.
285   // Prefer over `std::move(value.Get...())` so clang-tidy can warn about
286   // potential use-after-move mistakes.
287   std::string TakeString() &&;
288   Dict TakeDict() &&;
289   List TakeList() &&;
290 
291   // Represents a dictionary of string keys to Values.
292   class BASE_EXPORT GSL_OWNER Dict {
293    public:
294     using iterator = detail::dict_iterator;
295     using const_iterator = detail::const_dict_iterator;
296 
297     Dict();
298 
299     Dict(Dict&&) noexcept;
300     Dict& operator=(Dict&&) noexcept;
301 
302     // Deleted to prevent accidental copying.
303     Dict(const Dict&) = delete;
304     Dict& operator=(const Dict&) = delete;
305 
306     // Takes move_iterators iterators that return std::pair<std::string, Value>,
307     // and moves their values into a new Dict. Adding all entries at once
308     // results in a faster initial sort operation. Takes move iterators to avoid
309     // having to clone the input.
310     template <class IteratorType>
Dict(std::move_iterator<IteratorType> first,std::move_iterator<IteratorType> last)311     explicit Dict(std::move_iterator<IteratorType> first,
312                   std::move_iterator<IteratorType> last) {
313       // Need to move into a vector first, since `storage_` currently uses
314       // unique_ptrs.
315       std::vector<std::pair<std::string, std::unique_ptr<Value>>> values;
316       for (auto current = first; current != last; ++current) {
317         // With move iterators, no need to call Clone(), but do need to move
318         // to a temporary first, as accessing either field individually will
319         // directly from the iterator will delete the other field.
320         auto value = *current;
321         values.emplace_back(std::move(value.first),
322                             std::make_unique<Value>(std::move(value.second)));
323       }
324       storage_ =
325           flat_map<std::string, std::unique_ptr<Value>>(std::move(values));
326     }
327 
328     ~Dict();
329 
330     // Returns true if there are no entries in this dictionary and false
331     // otherwise.
332     bool empty() const;
333 
334     // Returns the number of entries in this dictionary.
335     size_t size() const;
336 
337     // Returns an iterator to the first entry in this dictionary.
338     iterator begin();
339     const_iterator begin() const;
340     const_iterator cbegin() const;
341 
342     // Returns an iterator following the last entry in this dictionary. May not
343     // be dereferenced.
344     iterator end();
345     const_iterator end() const;
346     const_iterator cend() const;
347 
348     // Returns true if `key` is an entry in this dictionary.
349     bool contains(base::StringPiece key) const;
350 
351     // Removes all entries from this dictionary.
352     REINITIALIZES_AFTER_MOVE void clear();
353 
354     // Removes the entry referenced by `pos` in this dictionary and returns an
355     // iterator to the entry following the removed entry.
356     iterator erase(iterator pos);
357     iterator erase(const_iterator pos);
358 
359     // Creates a deep copy of this dictionary.
360     Dict Clone() const;
361 
362     // Merges the entries from `dict` into this dictionary. If an entry with the
363     // same key exists in this dictionary and `dict`:
364     // - if both entries are dictionaries, they will be recursively merged
365     // - otherwise, the already-existing entry in this dictionary will be
366     //   overwritten with the entry from `dict`.
367     void Merge(Dict dict);
368 
369     // Finds the entry corresponding to `key` in this dictionary. Returns
370     // nullptr if there is no such entry.
371     const Value* Find(StringPiece key) const;
372     Value* Find(StringPiece key);
373 
374     // Similar to `Find()` above, but returns `absl::nullopt`/`nullptr` if the
375     // type of the entry does not match. `bool`, `int`, and `double` are
376     // returned in a wrapped `absl::optional`; blobs, `Value::Dict`, and
377     // `Value::List` are returned by pointer.
378     absl::optional<bool> FindBool(StringPiece key) const;
379     absl::optional<int> FindInt(StringPiece key) const;
380     // Returns a non-null value for both `Value::Type::DOUBLE` and
381     // `Value::Type::INT`, converting the latter to a double.
382     absl::optional<double> FindDouble(StringPiece key) const;
383     const std::string* FindString(StringPiece key) const;
384     std::string* FindString(StringPiece key);
385     const BlobStorage* FindBlob(StringPiece key) const;
386     const Dict* FindDict(StringPiece key) const;
387     Dict* FindDict(StringPiece key);
388     const List* FindList(StringPiece key) const;
389     List* FindList(StringPiece key);
390 
391     // If there's a value of the specified type at `key` in this dictionary,
392     // returns it. Otherwise, creates an empty container of the specified type,
393     // inserts it at `key`, and returns it. If there's a value of some other
394     // type at `key`, will overwrite that entry.
395     Dict* EnsureDict(StringPiece key);
396     List* EnsureList(StringPiece key);
397 
398     // Sets an entry with `key` and `value` in this dictionary, overwriting any
399     // existing entry with the same `key`. Returns a pointer to the set `value`.
400     Value* Set(StringPiece key, Value&& value) &;
401     Value* Set(StringPiece key, bool value) &;
402     template <typename T>
403     Value* Set(StringPiece, const T*) & = delete;
404     Value* Set(StringPiece key, int value) &;
405     Value* Set(StringPiece key, double value) &;
406     Value* Set(StringPiece key, StringPiece value) &;
407     Value* Set(StringPiece key, StringPiece16 value) &;
408     Value* Set(StringPiece key, const char* value) &;
409     Value* Set(StringPiece key, const char16_t* value) &;
410     Value* Set(StringPiece key, std::string&& value) &;
411     Value* Set(StringPiece key, BlobStorage&& value) &;
412     Value* Set(StringPiece key, Dict&& value) &;
413     Value* Set(StringPiece key, List&& value) &;
414 
415     // Rvalue overrides of the `Set` methods, which allow you to construct
416     // a `Value::Dict` builder-style:
417     //
418     // Value::Dict result =
419     //     Value::Dict()
420     //         .Set("key-1", "first value")
421     //         .Set("key-2", 2)
422     //         .Set("key-3", true)
423     //         .Set("nested-dictionary", Value::Dict()
424     //                                       .Set("nested-key-1", "value")
425     //                                       .Set("nested-key-2", true))
426     //         .Set("nested-list", Value::List()
427     //                                 .Append("nested-list-value")
428     //                                 .Append(5)
429     //                                 .Append(true));
430     //
431     // Each method returns a rvalue reference to `this`, so this is as efficient
432     // as stand-alone calls to `Set`, while also making it harder to
433     // accidentally insert items in the wrong dictionary.
434     //
435     // The equivalent code without using these builder-style methods:
436     //
437     // Value::Dict no_builder_example;
438     // no_builder_example.Set("key-1", "first value")
439     // no_builder_example.Set("key-2", 2)
440     // no_builder_example.Set("key-3", true)
441     // Value::Dict nested_dictionary;
442     // nested_dictionary.Set("nested-key-1", "value");
443     // nested_dictionary.Set("nested-key-2", true);
444     // no_builder_example.Set("nested_dictionary",
445     //                        std::move(nested_dictionary));
446     // Value::List nested_list;
447     // nested_list.Append("nested-list-value");
448     // nested_list.Append(5);
449     // nested_list.Append(true);
450     // no_builder_example.Set("nested-list", std::move(nested_list));
451     //
452     // Sometimes `git cl format` does a less than perfect job formatting these
453     // chained `Set` calls. In these cases you can use a trailing empty comment
454     // to influence the code formatting:
455     //
456     // Value::Dict result = Value::Dict().Set(
457     //     "nested",
458     //     base::Value::Dict().Set("key", "value").Set("other key", "other"));
459     //
460     // Value::Dict result = Value::Dict().Set("nested",
461     //                                        base::Value::Dict() //
462     //                                           .Set("key", "value")
463     //                                           .Set("other key", "value"));
464     //
465     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, Value&& value) &&;
466     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, bool value) &&;
467     template <typename T>
468     Dict&& Set(StringPiece, const T*) && = delete;
469     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, int value) &&;
470     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, double value) &&;
471     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, StringPiece value) &&;
472     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, StringPiece16 value) &&;
473     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, const char* value) &&;
474     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, const char16_t* value) &&;
475     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, std::string&& value) &&;
476     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, BlobStorage&& value) &&;
477     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, Dict&& value) &&;
478     Dict&& Set(StringPiece key, List&& value) &&;
479 
480     // Removes the entry corresponding to `key` from this dictionary. Returns
481     // true if an entry was removed or false otherwise.
482     bool Remove(StringPiece key);
483 
484     // Similar to `Remove()`, but returns the value corresponding to the removed
485     // entry or `absl::nullopt` otherwise.
486     absl::optional<Value> Extract(StringPiece key);
487 
488     // Equivalent to the above methods but operating on paths instead of keys.
489     // A path is shorthand syntax for referring to a key nested inside
490     // intermediate dictionaries, with components delimited by ".". Paths may
491     // not be empty.
492     //
493     // Prefer the non-path methods above when possible. Paths that have only one
494     // component (i.e. no dots in the path) should never use the path-based
495     // methods.
496     //
497     // Originally, the path-based APIs were the only way of specifying a key, so
498     // there are likely to be many legacy (and unnecessary) uses of the path
499     // APIs that do not actually require traversing nested dictionaries.
500     const Value* FindByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
501     Value* FindByDottedPath(StringPiece path);
502 
503     absl::optional<bool> FindBoolByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
504     absl::optional<int> FindIntByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
505     // Returns a non-null value for both `Value::Type::DOUBLE` and
506     // `Value::Type::INT`, converting the latter to a double.
507     absl::optional<double> FindDoubleByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
508     const std::string* FindStringByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
509     std::string* FindStringByDottedPath(StringPiece path);
510     const BlobStorage* FindBlobByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
511     const Dict* FindDictByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
512     Dict* FindDictByDottedPath(StringPiece path);
513     const List* FindListByDottedPath(StringPiece path) const;
514     List* FindListByDottedPath(StringPiece path);
515 
516     // Creates a new entry with a dictionary for any non-last component that is
517     // missing an entry while performing the path traversal. Will fail if any
518     // non-last component of the path refers to an already-existing entry that
519     // is not a dictionary. Returns `nullptr` on failure.
520     //
521     // Warning: repeatedly using this API to enter entries in the same nested
522     // dictionary is inefficient, so please do not write the following:
523     //
524     // bad_example.SetByDottedPath("a.nested.dictionary.field_1", 1);
525     // bad_example.SetByDottedPath("a.nested.dictionary.field_2", "value");
526     // bad_example.SetByDottedPath("a.nested.dictionary.field_3", 1);
527     //
528     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, Value&& value) &;
529     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, bool value) &;
530     template <typename T>
531     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece, const T*) & = delete;
532     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, int value) &;
533     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, double value) &;
534     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, StringPiece value) &;
535     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, StringPiece16 value) &;
536     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, const char* value) &;
537     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, const char16_t* value) &;
538     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, std::string&& value) &;
539     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, BlobStorage&& value) &;
540     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, Dict&& value) &;
541     Value* SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, List&& value) &;
542 
543     // Rvalue overrides of the `SetByDottedPath` methods, which allow you to
544     // construct a `Value::Dict` builder-style:
545     //
546     // Value::Dict result =
547     //     Value::Dict()
548     //         .SetByDottedPath("a.nested.dictionary.with.key-1", "first value")
549     //         .Set("local-key-1", 2));
550     //
551     // Each method returns a rvalue reference to `this`, so this is as efficient
552     // as (and less mistake-prone than) stand-alone calls to `Set`.
553     //
554     // Warning: repeatedly using this API to enter entries in the same nested
555     // dictionary is inefficient, so do not write this:
556     //
557     // Value::Dict bad_example =
558     //   Value::Dict()
559     //     .SetByDottedPath("nested.dictionary.key-1", "first value")
560     //     .SetByDottedPath("nested.dictionary.key-2", "second value")
561     //     .SetByDottedPath("nested.dictionary.key-3", "third value");
562     //
563     // Instead, simply write this
564     //
565     // Value::Dict good_example =
566     //   Value::Dict()
567     //     .Set("nested",
568     //          base::Value::Dict()
569     //            .Set("dictionary",
570     //                 base::Value::Dict()
571     //                   .Set(key-1", "first value")
572     //                   .Set(key-2", "second value")
573     //                   .Set(key-3", "third value")));
574     //
575     //
576     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, Value&& value) &&;
577     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, bool value) &&;
578     template <typename T>
579     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece, const T*) && = delete;
580     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, int value) &&;
581     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, double value) &&;
582     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, StringPiece value) &&;
583     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, StringPiece16 value) &&;
584     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, const char* value) &&;
585     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, const char16_t* value) &&;
586     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, std::string&& value) &&;
587     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, BlobStorage&& value) &&;
588     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, Dict&& value) &&;
589     Dict&& SetByDottedPath(StringPiece path, List&& value) &&;
590 
591     bool RemoveByDottedPath(StringPiece path);
592 
593     absl::optional<Value> ExtractByDottedPath(StringPiece path);
594 
595     // Estimates dynamic memory usage. Requires tracing support
596     // (enable_base_tracing gn flag), otherwise always returns 0. See
597     // base/trace_event/memory_usage_estimator.h for more info.
598     size_t EstimateMemoryUsage() const;
599 
600     // Serializes to a string for logging and debug purposes.
601     std::string DebugString() const;
602 
603 #if BUILDFLAG(ENABLE_BASE_TRACING)
604     // Write this object into a trace.
605     void WriteIntoTrace(perfetto::TracedValue) const;
606 #endif  // BUILDFLAG(ENABLE_BASE_TRACING)
607 
608    private:
609     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Dict& lhs, const Dict& rhs);
610     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator!=(const Dict& lhs, const Dict& rhs);
611     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator<(const Dict& lhs, const Dict& rhs);
612     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator>(const Dict& lhs, const Dict& rhs);
613     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator<=(const Dict& lhs, const Dict& rhs);
614     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator>=(const Dict& lhs, const Dict& rhs);
615 
616     explicit Dict(const flat_map<std::string, std::unique_ptr<Value>>& storage);
617 
618     // TODO(dcheng): Replace with `flat_map<std::string, Value>` once no caller
619     // relies on stability of pointers anymore.
620     flat_map<std::string, std::unique_ptr<Value>> storage_;
621   };
622 
623   // Represents a list of Values.
624   class BASE_EXPORT GSL_OWNER List {
625    public:
626     using iterator = CheckedContiguousIterator<Value>;
627     using const_iterator = CheckedContiguousConstIterator<Value>;
628     using reverse_iterator = std::reverse_iterator<iterator>;
629     using const_reverse_iterator = std::reverse_iterator<const_iterator>;
630     using value_type = Value;
631 
632     // Creates a list with the given capacity reserved.
633     // Correctly using this will greatly reduce the code size and improve
634     // performance when creating a list whose size is known up front.
635     static List with_capacity(size_t capacity);
636 
637     List();
638 
639     List(List&&) noexcept;
640     List& operator=(List&&) noexcept;
641 
642     // Deleted to prevent accidental copying.
643     List(const List&) = delete;
644     List& operator=(const List&) = delete;
645 
646     ~List();
647 
648     // Returns true if there are no values in this list and false otherwise.
649     bool empty() const;
650 
651     // Returns the number of values in this list.
652     size_t size() const;
653 
654     // Returns an iterator to the first value in this list.
655     iterator begin();
656     const_iterator begin() const;
657     const_iterator cbegin() const;
658 
659     // Returns an iterator following the last value in this list. May not be
660     // dereferenced.
661     iterator end();
662     const_iterator end() const;
663     const_iterator cend() const;
664 
665     // Returns a reverse iterator preceding the first value in this list. May
666     // not be dereferenced.
667     reverse_iterator rend();
668     const_reverse_iterator rend() const;
669 
670     // Returns a reverse iterator to the last value in this list.
671     reverse_iterator rbegin();
672     const_reverse_iterator rbegin() const;
673 
674     // Returns a reference to the first value in the container. Fails with
675     // `CHECK()` if the list is empty.
676     const Value& front() const;
677     Value& front();
678 
679     // Returns a reference to the last value in the container. Fails with
680     // `CHECK()` if the list is empty.
681     const Value& back() const;
682     Value& back();
683 
684     // Increase the capacity of the backing container, but does not change
685     // the size. Assume all existing iterators will be invalidated.
686     void reserve(size_t capacity);
687 
688     // Resizes the list.
689     // If `new_size` is greater than current size, the extra elements in the
690     // back will be destroyed.
691     // If `new_size` is less than current size, new default-initialized elements
692     // will be added to the back.
693     // Assume all existing iterators will be invalidated.
694     void resize(size_t new_size);
695 
696     // Returns a reference to the value at `index` in this list. Fails with a
697     // `CHECK()` if `index >= size()`.
698     const Value& operator[](size_t index) const;
699     Value& operator[](size_t index);
700 
701     // Removes all value from this list.
702     REINITIALIZES_AFTER_MOVE void clear();
703 
704     // Removes the value referenced by `pos` in this list and returns an
705     // iterator to the value following the removed value.
706     iterator erase(iterator pos);
707     const_iterator erase(const_iterator pos);
708 
709     // Remove the values in the range [`first`, `last`). Returns iterator to the
710     // first value following the removed range, which is `last`. If `first` ==
711     // `last`, removes nothing and returns `last`.
712     iterator erase(iterator first, iterator last);
713     const_iterator erase(const_iterator first, const_iterator last);
714 
715     // Creates a deep copy of this dictionary.
716     List Clone() const;
717 
718     // Appends `value` to the end of this list.
719     void Append(Value&& value) &;
720     void Append(bool value) &;
721     template <typename T>
722     void Append(const T*) & = delete;
723     void Append(int value) &;
724     void Append(double value) &;
725     void Append(StringPiece value) &;
726     void Append(StringPiece16 value) &;
727     void Append(const char* value) &;
728     void Append(const char16_t* value) &;
729     void Append(std::string&& value) &;
730     void Append(BlobStorage&& value) &;
731     void Append(Dict&& value) &;
732     void Append(List&& value) &;
733 
734     // Rvalue overrides of the `Append` methods, which allow you to construct
735     // a `Value::List` builder-style:
736     //
737     // Value::List result =
738     //   Value::List().Append("first value").Append(2).Append(true);
739     //
740     // Each method returns a rvalue reference to `this`, so this is as efficient
741     // as stand-alone calls to `Append`, while at the same time making it harder
742     // to accidentally append to the wrong list.
743     //
744     // The equivalent code without using these builder-style methods:
745     //
746     // Value::List no_builder_example;
747     // no_builder_example.Append("first value");
748     // no_builder_example.Append(2);
749     // no_builder_example.Append(true);
750     //
751     List&& Append(Value&& value) &&;
752     List&& Append(bool value) &&;
753     template <typename T>
754     List&& Append(const T*) && = delete;
755     List&& Append(int value) &&;
756     List&& Append(double value) &&;
757     List&& Append(StringPiece value) &&;
758     List&& Append(StringPiece16 value) &&;
759     List&& Append(const char* value) &&;
760     List&& Append(const char16_t* value) &&;
761     List&& Append(std::string&& value) &&;
762     List&& Append(BlobStorage&& value) &&;
763     List&& Append(Dict&& value) &&;
764     List&& Append(List&& value) &&;
765 
766     // Inserts `value` before `pos` in this list. Returns an iterator to the
767     // inserted value.
768     // TODO(dcheng): Should this provide the same set of overloads that Append()
769     // does?
770     iterator Insert(const_iterator pos, Value&& value);
771 
772     // Erases all values equal to `value` from this list.
773     size_t EraseValue(const Value& value);
774 
775     // Erases all values for which `predicate` evaluates to true from this list.
776     template <typename Predicate>
EraseIf(Predicate predicate)777     size_t EraseIf(Predicate predicate) {
778       return base::EraseIf(storage_, predicate);
779     }
780 
781     // Estimates dynamic memory usage. Requires tracing support
782     // (enable_base_tracing gn flag), otherwise always returns 0. See
783     // base/trace_event/memory_usage_estimator.h for more info.
784     size_t EstimateMemoryUsage() const;
785 
786     // Serializes to a string for logging and debug purposes.
787     std::string DebugString() const;
788 
789 #if BUILDFLAG(ENABLE_BASE_TRACING)
790     // Write this object into a trace.
791     void WriteIntoTrace(perfetto::TracedValue) const;
792 #endif  // BUILDFLAG(ENABLE_BASE_TRACING)
793 
794    private:
795     using ListStorage = std::vector<Value>;
796 
797     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const List& lhs, const List& rhs);
798     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator!=(const List& lhs, const List& rhs);
799     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator<(const List& lhs, const List& rhs);
800     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator>(const List& lhs, const List& rhs);
801     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator<=(const List& lhs, const List& rhs);
802     BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator>=(const List& lhs, const List& rhs);
803 
804     explicit List(const std::vector<Value>& storage);
805 
806     std::vector<Value> storage_;
807   };
808 
809   // Note: Do not add more types. See the file-level comment above for why.
810 
811   // Comparison operators so that Values can easily be used with standard
812   // library algorithms and associative containers.
813   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, const Value& rhs);
814   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, const Value& rhs);
815   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator<(const Value& lhs, const Value& rhs);
816   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator>(const Value& lhs, const Value& rhs);
817   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator<=(const Value& lhs, const Value& rhs);
818   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator>=(const Value& lhs, const Value& rhs);
819 
820   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, bool rhs);
821   friend bool operator==(bool lhs, const Value& rhs) { return rhs == lhs; }
822   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, bool rhs) { return !(lhs == rhs); }
823   friend bool operator!=(bool lhs, const Value& rhs) { return !(lhs == rhs); }
824   template <typename T>
825   friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, const T* rhs) = delete;
826   template <typename T>
827   friend bool operator==(const T* lhs, const Value& rhs) = delete;
828   template <typename T>
829   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, const T* rhs) = delete;
830   template <typename T>
831   friend bool operator!=(const T* lhs, const Value& rhs) = delete;
832   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, int rhs);
833   friend bool operator==(int lhs, const Value& rhs) { return rhs == lhs; }
834   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, int rhs) { return !(lhs == rhs); }
835   friend bool operator!=(int lhs, const Value& rhs) { return !(lhs == rhs); }
836   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, double rhs);
837   friend bool operator==(double lhs, const Value& rhs) { return rhs == lhs; }
838   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, double rhs) { return !(lhs == rhs); }
839   friend bool operator!=(double lhs, const Value& rhs) { return !(lhs == rhs); }
840   // Note: StringPiece16 overload intentionally omitted: Value internally stores
841   // strings as UTF-8. While it is possible to implement a comparison operator
842   // that would not require first creating a new UTF-8 string from the UTF-16
843   // string argument, it is simpler to just not implement it at all for a rare
844   // use case.
845   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, StringPiece rhs);
846   friend bool operator==(StringPiece lhs, const Value& rhs) {
847     return rhs == lhs;
848   }
849   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, StringPiece rhs) {
850     return !(lhs == rhs);
851   }
852   friend bool operator!=(StringPiece lhs, const Value& rhs) {
853     return !(lhs == rhs);
854   }
855   friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, const char* rhs) {
856     return lhs == StringPiece(rhs);
857   }
858   friend bool operator==(const char* lhs, const Value& rhs) {
859     return rhs == lhs;
860   }
861   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, const char* rhs) {
862     return !(lhs == rhs);
863   }
864   friend bool operator!=(const char* lhs, const Value& rhs) {
865     return !(lhs == rhs);
866   }
867   friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, const std::string& rhs) {
868     return lhs == StringPiece(rhs);
869   }
870   friend bool operator==(const std::string& lhs, const Value& rhs) {
871     return rhs == lhs;
872   }
873   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, const std::string& rhs) {
874     return !(lhs == rhs);
875   }
876   friend bool operator!=(const std::string& lhs, const Value& rhs) {
877     return !(lhs == rhs);
878   }
879   // Note: Blob support intentionally omitted as an experiment for potentially
880   // wholly removing Blob support from Value itself in the future.
881   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, const Value::Dict& rhs);
882   friend bool operator==(const Value::Dict& lhs, const Value& rhs) {
883     return rhs == lhs;
884   }
885   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, const Value::Dict& rhs) {
886     return !(lhs == rhs);
887   }
888   friend bool operator!=(const Value::Dict& lhs, const Value& rhs) {
889     return !(lhs == rhs);
890   }
891   BASE_EXPORT friend bool operator==(const Value& lhs, const Value::List& rhs);
892   friend bool operator==(const Value::List& lhs, const Value& rhs) {
893     return rhs == lhs;
894   }
895   friend bool operator!=(const Value& lhs, const Value::List& rhs) {
896     return !(lhs == rhs);
897   }
898   friend bool operator!=(const Value::List& lhs, const Value& rhs) {
899     return !(lhs == rhs);
900   }
901 
902   // Estimates dynamic memory usage. Requires tracing support
903   // (enable_base_tracing gn flag), otherwise always returns 0. See
904   // base/trace_event/memory_usage_estimator.h for more info.
905   size_t EstimateMemoryUsage() const;
906 
907   // Serializes to a string for logging and debug purposes.
908   std::string DebugString() const;
909 
910 #if BUILDFLAG(ENABLE_BASE_TRACING)
911   // Write this object into a trace.
912   void WriteIntoTrace(perfetto::TracedValue) const;
913 #endif  // BUILDFLAG(ENABLE_BASE_TRACING)
914 
915   template <typename Visitor>
Visit(Visitor && visitor)916   auto Visit(Visitor&& visitor) const {
917     return absl::visit(std::forward<Visitor>(visitor), data_);
918   }
919 
920  private:
921   // For access to DoubleStorage.
922   friend class ValueView;
923 
924   // Special case for doubles, which are aligned to 8 bytes on some
925   // 32-bit architectures. In this case, a simple declaration as a
926   // double member would make the whole union 8 byte-aligned, which
927   // would also force 4 bytes of wasted padding space before it in
928   // the Value layout.
929   //
930   // To override this, store the value as an array of 32-bit integers, and
931   // perform the appropriate bit casts when reading / writing to it.
932   class BASE_EXPORT DoubleStorage {
933    public:
934     explicit DoubleStorage(double v);
935     DoubleStorage(const DoubleStorage&) = default;
936     DoubleStorage& operator=(const DoubleStorage&) = default;
937 
938     // Provide an implicit conversion to double to simplify the use of visitors
939     // with `Value::Visit()`. Otherwise, visitors would need a branch for
940     // handling `DoubleStorage` like:
941     //
942     //   value.Visit([] (const auto& member) {
943     //     using T = std::decay_t<decltype(member)>;
944     //     if constexpr (std::is_same_v<T, Value::DoubleStorage>) {
945     //       SomeFunction(double{member});
946     //     } else {
947     //       SomeFunction(member);
948     //     }
949     //   });
950     operator double() const { return base::bit_cast<double>(v_); }
951 
952    private:
953     friend bool operator==(const DoubleStorage& lhs, const DoubleStorage& rhs) {
954       return double{lhs} == double{rhs};
955     }
956 
957     friend bool operator!=(const DoubleStorage& lhs, const DoubleStorage& rhs) {
958       return !(lhs == rhs);
959     }
960 
961     friend bool operator<(const DoubleStorage& lhs, const DoubleStorage& rhs) {
962       return double{lhs} < double{rhs};
963     }
964 
965     friend bool operator>(const DoubleStorage& lhs, const DoubleStorage& rhs) {
966       return rhs < lhs;
967     }
968 
969     friend bool operator<=(const DoubleStorage& lhs, const DoubleStorage& rhs) {
970       return !(rhs < lhs);
971     }
972 
973     friend bool operator>=(const DoubleStorage& lhs, const DoubleStorage& rhs) {
974       return !(lhs < rhs);
975     }
976 
977     alignas(4) std::array<char, sizeof(double)> v_;
978   };
979 
980   // Internal constructors, allowing the simplify the implementation of Clone().
981   explicit Value(absl::monostate);
982   explicit Value(DoubleStorage storage);
983 
984   // A helper for static functions used for cloning a Value or a ValueView.
985   class CloningHelper;
986 
987   absl::variant<absl::monostate,
988                 bool,
989                 int,
990                 DoubleStorage,
991                 std::string,
992                 BlobStorage,
993                 Dict,
994                 List>
995       data_;
996 };
997 
998 // Adapter so `Value::Dict` or `Value::List` can be directly passed to JSON
999 // serialization methods without having to clone the contents and transfer
1000 // ownership of the clone to a `Value` wrapper object.
1001 //
1002 // Like `StringPiece` and `span<T>`, this adapter does NOT retain ownership. Any
1003 // underlying object that is passed by reference (i.e. `std::string`,
1004 // `Value::BlobStorage`, `Value::Dict`, `Value::List`, or `Value`) MUST remain
1005 // live as long as there is a `ValueView` referencing it.
1006 //
1007 // While it might be nice to just use the `absl::variant` type directly, the
1008 // need to use `std::reference_wrapper` makes it clunky. `absl::variant` and
1009 // `std::reference_wrapper` both support implicit construction, but C++ only
1010 // allows at most one user-defined conversion in an implicit conversion
1011 // sequence. If this adapter and its implicit constructors did not exist,
1012 // callers would need to use `std::ref` or `std::cref` to pass `Value::Dict` or
1013 // `Value::List` to a function with a `ValueView` parameter.
1014 class BASE_EXPORT GSL_POINTER ValueView {
1015  public:
1016   ValueView() = default;
ValueView(bool value)1017   ValueView(bool value) : data_view_(value) {}
1018   template <typename T>
1019   ValueView(const T*) = delete;
ValueView(int value)1020   ValueView(int value) : data_view_(value) {}
ValueView(double value)1021   ValueView(double value)
1022       : data_view_(absl::in_place_type_t<Value::DoubleStorage>(), value) {}
ValueView(StringPiece value)1023   ValueView(StringPiece value) : data_view_(value) {}
ValueView(const char * value)1024   ValueView(const char* value) : ValueView(StringPiece(value)) {}
ValueView(const std::string & value)1025   ValueView(const std::string& value) : ValueView(StringPiece(value)) {}
1026   // Note: UTF-16 is intentionally not supported. ValueView is intended to be a
1027   // low-cost view abstraction, but Value internally represents strings as
1028   // UTF-8, so it would not be possible to implement this without allocating an
1029   // entirely new UTF-8 string.
ValueView(const Value::BlobStorage & value)1030   ValueView(const Value::BlobStorage& value) : data_view_(value) {}
ValueView(const Value::Dict & value)1031   ValueView(const Value::Dict& value) : data_view_(value) {}
ValueView(const Value::List & value)1032   ValueView(const Value::List& value) : data_view_(value) {}
1033   ValueView(const Value& value);
1034 
1035   // This is the only 'getter' method provided as `ValueView` is not intended
1036   // to be a general replacement of `Value`.
1037   template <typename Visitor>
Visit(Visitor && visitor)1038   auto Visit(Visitor&& visitor) const {
1039     return absl::visit(std::forward<Visitor>(visitor), data_view_);
1040   }
1041 
1042   // Returns a clone of the underlying Value.
1043   Value ToValue() const;
1044 
1045  private:
1046   using ViewType =
1047       absl::variant<absl::monostate,
1048                     bool,
1049                     int,
1050                     Value::DoubleStorage,
1051                     StringPiece,
1052                     std::reference_wrapper<const Value::BlobStorage>,
1053                     std::reference_wrapper<const Value::Dict>,
1054                     std::reference_wrapper<const Value::List>>;
1055 
1056  public:
1057   using DoubleStorageForTest = Value::DoubleStorage;
data_view_for_test()1058   const ViewType& data_view_for_test() const { return data_view_; }
1059 
1060  private:
1061   ViewType data_view_;
1062 };
1063 
1064 // This interface is implemented by classes that know how to serialize
1065 // Value objects.
1066 class BASE_EXPORT ValueSerializer {
1067  public:
1068   virtual ~ValueSerializer();
1069 
1070   virtual bool Serialize(ValueView root) = 0;
1071 };
1072 
1073 // This interface is implemented by classes that know how to deserialize Value
1074 // objects.
1075 class BASE_EXPORT ValueDeserializer {
1076  public:
1077   virtual ~ValueDeserializer();
1078 
1079   // This method deserializes the subclass-specific format into a Value object.
1080   // If the return value is non-NULL, the caller takes ownership of returned
1081   // Value.
1082   //
1083   // If the return value is nullptr, and if `error_code` is non-nullptr,
1084   // `*error_code` will be set to an integer value representing the underlying
1085   // error. See "enum ErrorCode" below for more detail about the integer value.
1086   //
1087   // If `error_message` is non-nullptr, it will be filled in with a formatted
1088   // error message including the location of the error if appropriate.
1089   virtual std::unique_ptr<Value> Deserialize(int* error_code,
1090                                              std::string* error_message) = 0;
1091 
1092   // The integer-valued error codes form four groups:
1093   //  - The value 0 means no error.
1094   //  - Values between 1 and 999 inclusive mean an error in the data (i.e.
1095   //    content). The bytes being deserialized are not in the right format.
1096   //  - Values 1000 and above mean an error in the metadata (i.e. context). The
1097   //    file could not be read, the network is down, etc.
1098   //  - Negative values are reserved.
1099   //
1100   // These values are persisted to logs. Entries should not be renumbered and
1101   // numeric values should never be reused.
1102   enum ErrorCode {
1103     kErrorCodeNoError = 0,
1104     // kErrorCodeInvalidFormat is a generic error code for "the data is not in
1105     // the right format". Subclasses of ValueDeserializer may return other
1106     // values for more specific errors.
1107     kErrorCodeInvalidFormat = 1,
1108     // kErrorCodeFirstMetadataError is the minimum value (inclusive) of the
1109     // range of metadata errors.
1110     kErrorCodeFirstMetadataError = 1000,
1111   };
1112 
1113   // The `error_code` argument can be one of the ErrorCode values, but it is
1114   // not restricted to only being 0, 1 or 1000. Subclasses of ValueDeserializer
1115   // can define their own error code values.
ErrorCodeIsDataError(int error_code)1116   static inline bool ErrorCodeIsDataError(int error_code) {
1117     return (kErrorCodeInvalidFormat <= error_code) &&
1118            (error_code < kErrorCodeFirstMetadataError);
1119   }
1120 };
1121 
1122 // Stream operator so Values can be pretty printed by gtest.
1123 BASE_EXPORT std::ostream& operator<<(std::ostream& out, const Value& value);
1124 BASE_EXPORT std::ostream& operator<<(std::ostream& out,
1125                                      const Value::Dict& dict);
1126 BASE_EXPORT std::ostream& operator<<(std::ostream& out,
1127                                      const Value::List& list);
1128 
1129 // Stream operator so that enum class Types can be used in log statements.
1130 BASE_EXPORT std::ostream& operator<<(std::ostream& out,
1131                                      const Value::Type& type);
1132 
1133 }  // namespace base
1134 
1135 #endif  // BASE_VALUES_H_
1136